Like so many people out there, I am horrified at the events that transpired on November 13 in Paris. Only people who are completely devoid of any kind of feeling would not feel something. I was listening to the Germany-France soccer game on the radio when the bombs went off and news of the attacks started coming through. It really, really hurt.
In all of this, I have come to think about the very interesting reaction to the attacks. Before I dive into those observations, I need to make it absolutely clear that my thoughts and prayers are with the people of France at these moments when they are under attack. I wish that they find peace and justice from all this.
That said, I want to point out some interesting things from recent human history.
In 2014, 43 students in Mexico disappeared after being taken by police (or military, or paramilitary) forces. There are very strong indicators that they are now dead, and that local and state (and even federal) authorities had a hand in their death. While there were many marches in Mexico — and a few in other countries like the United States — hardly anyone else noticed. There was no continuing coverage or “breaking news” on television. CNN was not interviewing everyone and anyone in Mexico about what happened. No world leaders gathered to demand a thorough investigation.
In fact, since the latest drug war erupted in Mexico in the Calderón Administration, tens of thousands of people have died and many have gone missing. That’s just south of the border from the most powerful nation on the face of the earth. The best estimates put the number of dead at over 164,000… More than the number of civilian deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan during the same time period. Again, no one really bats an eye about this.
And that’s just Mexico. People are getting killed in other military conflicts in other parts of the world as well. Allies of the United States have had tens of thousands of people die. But we seem to be okay with that collectively because it’s war, and war comes at a price. The people in Paris last night were not soldiers, so let’s talk about the non-soldiers.
As I’ve been covering in my writings and on social media, Baltimore has a murder rate that is the highest since the crack-cocaine epidemic of the 1990s. As I’m writing this, the number of people killed by violence in Baltimore in 2015 is at 299. That’s 299 dead in 318 days for a per day rate of 0.94 murders, putting Baltimore on pace for 343 murders for 2015 and second only to the 353 murders in 1993. But that’s not breaking news. I assure you that once the city hits 300 tonight, probably during the Democratic Presidential Debate, no one will ask former Governor Martin O’Malley what he would do to stop the violence in Baltimore and in other cities in the United States.
The Joker was right:
When things are “part of the plan,” we don’t panic. We kind of just shrug our shoulders and go on with life. We might shake our heads a little bit, or some of us may go protest for a couple of days. For the most part, however, we move on with our lives. Ah, but if you have the same number of deaths in a year and compress them into a day or two, then everyone loses their mind. Then they build memorials. Then world leaders make statements.
I guess it’s human nature to react strongly against a lot of deaths in a short amount of time and to get used to — or even comfortable with — the same number of deaths over a very long time. Or, if those deaths happen in some other place to people who are not like us, then that’s their problem and why should I give up something, or someone, for it? “Let them deal with it,” some say. “Those poor people,” say the others. And only a few will try to do something about it.
Yeah, I feel a little guilty writing this. I feel like I’m minimizing the deaths of people who had done absolutely nothing wrong and lived in a country that is relatively stable. You expect people to die in war zones, inner cities, collapsed states. You certainly don’t expect it in Paris. And, if Parisians are not safe, how can we be safe anywhere? I think that right there is why we’re so fascinated with what has happened.
René F. Najera, DrPH
I'm a Doctor of Public Health, having studied at the Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health.
All opinions are my own and in no way represent anyone else or any of the organizations for which I work.
About History of Vaccines: I am the editor of the History of Vaccines site, a project of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia. Please read the About page on the site for more information.
About Epidemiological: I am the sole contributor to Epidemiological, my personal blog to discuss all sorts of issues. It also has an About page you should check out.